In partnership with

The eternal question keeps popping up in my DMs: "Should I focus on building my community on Threads or stick with Twitter/X?"

After analyzing engagement patterns across both platforms and interviewing 50+ creators who've built communities on each, I've got some surprising insights to share.

The Community Building Landscape: 2025 Edition

Here's what the data tells us about community growth on both platforms:

Threads Advantages:

• Higher initial engagement rates for new accounts (average 3.2% vs Twitter's 1.8%)

• Less saturated creator space means more opportunity to stand out

• Algorithm favors conversations over viral content, building deeper connections

• Cross-platform integration with Instagram brings built-in audience discovery

Twitter/X Advantages:

• Established creator economy with monetization options

• Real-time conversations during trending events create instant community bonds

• Thread format allows for deeper storytelling and value delivery

• Mature discovery systems help you find your exact niche community

Want to get the most out of ChatGPT?

ChatGPT is a superpower if you know how to use it correctly.

Discover how HubSpot's guide to AI can elevate both your productivity and creativity to get more things done.

Learn to automate tasks, enhance decision-making, and foster innovation with the power of AI.

Download the free guide

The Engagement Reality Check

Let's talk numbers that matter:

Average Time to First 1,000 Engaged Followers:

• Threads: 4-6 months with consistent posting

• Twitter: 6-9 months (but followers tend to be more engaged long-term)

Community Interaction Quality:

• Threads: Higher reply-to-like ratios (1:4) indicate more conversation

• Twitter: Lower reply ratios (1:8) but deeper conversations in replies

Platform-Specific Community Building Strategies

Threads: The Conversation Catalyst

What works:

• Share behind-the-scenes content and personal insights

• Ask open-ended questions that spark discussion

• Engage authentically in others' threads within 30 minutes of posting

• Use Instagram's story features to drive Threads engagement

Pro tip: Threads' algorithm rewards consistent engagement over follower count. A creator with 500 active followers often outperforms someone with 5,000 passive ones.

Twitter: The Authority Builder

What works:

• Share industry insights and hot takes on trending topics

• Create valuable thread series that people bookmark and share

• Participate in Twitter chats and trending conversations

• Leverage Twitter Spaces for real-time community building

Pro tip: Twitter's search functionality makes your content discoverable long after posting. Optimize with relevant keywords.

The Hybrid Approach: Why You Don't Have to Choose

Here's the strategy I recommend to most creators:

Phase 1 (Months 1-3): Focus 70% effort on Threads for faster initial growth Phase 2 (Months 4-6): Shift to 60% Twitter, 40% Threads as you establish authority Phase 3 (Month 7+): Maintain both with platform-specific content strategies

The Bottom Line

Choose Threads if:

• You're starting from zero and want faster initial traction

• Your content style is conversational and personal

• You already have an Instagram presence to leverage

• You prefer quality engagement over quantity

Choose Twitter if:

• You want to establish thought leadership in your industry

• You create educational or analytical content

• You're comfortable with slower but potentially more valuable growth

• Monetization is a near-term goal

Choose both if:

• You have bandwidth for 2+ posts daily across platforms

• Your content can be adapted for different platform cultures

• You want to maximize your reach and hedge your bets

This Week's Action Items

1. Audit your current engagement rates on both platforms

2. Test one piece of content on both platforms and compare performance

3. Identify 10 accounts to engage with daily on your chosen primary platform

4. Set a 30-day experiment focusing 80% effort on one platform