In partnership with

Welcome to today's edition of Social Media Growth Guide!

Here's a wake-up call that might sting: A creator with 1,000 engaged followers will outperform someone with 10,000 passive followers every single time.

Why? Because social media algorithms in 2025 prioritize one metric above all others: engagement rate.

What Is Social Media Engagement Rate (And Why It Matters More Than Ever)

Your engagement rate is the percentage of your audience that actively interacts with your content through likes, comments, shares, and saves. Most brands and influencers fall into the 1% to 3% engagement rate range, but here's what the numbers really mean:

• Less than 1%: Your content strategy needs immediate attention

• 1-3%: You're in the average zone (but average doesn't win)

• Above 3%: You're in the top tier of social media performers

TikTok leads with a 2.50% engagement rate, while Instagram sits at 0.50% in 2025 - showing just how platform-specific these metrics can be.

The future of AI customer service is at Pioneer

There’s only one place where CS leaders at the cutting edge will gather to explore the incredible opportunities presented by AI Agents: Pioneer.

Pioneer is a summit for AI customer service leaders to come together and discuss the trends and trajectory of AI and customer service. You’ll hear from innovators at Anthropic, Toast, Rocket Money, Boston Consulting Group, and more—plus a special guest keynote delivered by Gary Vaynerchuk.

You’ll also get the chance to meet the team behind Fin, the #1 AI Agent for customer service. The whole team will be on site, from Intercom’s PhD AI engineers, to product executives and leaders, and the solutions engineers deploying Fin in the market.

Join Pioneer in-person or online on October 9th, 2025. Register today.

The Algorithm Truth: Why Engagement Rate Rules Supreme

Social media platforms are businesses, and their goal is keeping users on the platform longer. When your content generates high engagement, you're essentially helping the platform achieve this goal. The result? Higher engagement rates lead to exponentially better organic reach.

Think of it this way: Would you rather have 10,000 followers where only 50 people see your posts, or 1,000 followers where 500 people see and engage with your content?

7 Proven Strategies to Boost Your Social Media Engagement Rate in 2025

1. Master the Art of Conversation Starters

Instead of broadcasting, start conversations. End your posts with questions, polls, or "this or that" scenarios. Use various formats like videos, polls and stories to keep things fresh.

Pro Tip: Use the "controversy technique" - share a mildly controversial but professional opinion in your niche. Nothing drives engagement like respectful debate.

2. Leverage User-Generated Content (UGC)

Featuring user-generated content (UGC) not only builds trust but also encourages more engagement, which boosts reach further. Create branded hashtags and encourage your community to use them.

3. Time Your Posts for Maximum Impact

Posting when your audience is most engaged is a great tactic for boosting engagement. Use your platform's analytics to identify when your audience is most active, then post 30-60 minutes before those peak times.

4. Respond Lightning Fast

Replying to comments promptly and running interactive polls tend to increase user involvement. Aim to respond to comments within the first hour of posting - this signals to the algorithm that your content sparks conversation.

5. Create "Save-Worthy" Content

Saves are the new shares. Create content that people want to reference later: templates, checklists, tutorials, or inspirational quotes. Saves signal high value to algorithms.

6. Use the "Hook-Story-CTA" Framework

• Hook: Grab attention in the first 3 seconds

• Story: Provide value through narrative

• CTA: Always include a clear call-to-action

7. Go Beyond the Feed

Direct messages, replies and story interactions all count toward engagement numbers. Don't neglect Stories, Reels, and DM conversations - they all contribute to your overall engagement rate.

The Engagement Rate Formula (Calculate Yours Now)

Basic Engagement Rate Formula: (Total Engagements ÷ Total Followers) × 100 = Engagement Rate %

Advanced Formula (More Accurate): (Total Engagements ÷ Total Reach) × 100 = True Engagement Rate %

Use the advanced formula for a more accurate picture, especially if you have high follower counts but lower reach.

Platform-Specific Engagement Benchmarks for 2025

• Instagram: 0.50% average (aim for 1%+)

• TikTok: 2.50% average (aim for 3%+)

• Facebook: 0.15% average (aim for 0.25%+)

• X (Twitter): 0.15% average (aim for 0.5%+)

• LinkedIn: 1-3% average (aim for 2%+)

Your 30-Day Engagement Rate Challenge

Week 1: Audit your current engagement rate and identify your top 5 performing posts 

Week 2: Implement conversation starters and respond to every comment within 1 hour 

Week 3: Create and test user-generated content campaigns 

Week 4: Analyze results and double down on what worked

The Bottom Line: Quality Always Wins

Remember, social media is called "social" for a reason. A high engagement rate indicates that the content is resonating with the audience and generating interest.

Stop chasing vanity metrics. Start building a community that actually cares about what you have to say. Your engagement rate—and your business results—will thank you.

That's a wrap!