How to Build a Social Media Community: Why Engagement Beats Followers

Learn why building an engaged social media community is more valuable than follower counts. Discover proven strategies for community building, private groups, and authentic engagement that drive real business growth.

In partnership with

Welcome to today's edition of Social Media Growth Guide!

Remember when we all obsessed over follower counts? Those days are fading fast.

In 2025, the social media landscape has fundamentally transformed. The brands winning on social aren't the ones with millions of followers—they're the ones building genuine communities where people actually want to hang out.

Here's why community has become the most valuable asset in your social media strategy.

Find your customers on Roku this Black Friday

As with any digital ad campaign, the important thing is to reach streaming audiences who will convert. To that end, Roku’s self-service Ads Manager stands ready with powerful segmentation and targeting options. After all, you know your customers, and we know our streaming audience.

Worried it’s too late to spin up new Black Friday creative? With Roku Ads Manager, you can easily import and augment existing creative assets from your social channels. We also have AI-assisted upscaling, so every ad is primed for CTV.

Once you’ve done this, then you can easily set up A/B tests to flight different creative variants and Black Friday offers. If you’re a Shopify brand, you can even run shoppable ads directly on-screen so viewers can purchase with just a click of their Roku remote.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Why Community Trumps Follower Count

The Numbers Don't Lie

While everyone chased vanity metrics, something interesting happened: engagement started mattering more than reach. Research shows that 49% of consumers say the originality of content makes their favorite brands stand out on social, and 36% say how brands engage with their followers is what truly differentiates them.

Think about it. Would you rather have:

  • 100,000 followers who scroll past your content?

  • Or 10,000 engaged community members who comment, share, and advocate for your brand?

The second option wins every time.

The Migration to Private Spaces

Public social feeds are losing their appeal as users migrate to private groups and niche communities on platforms like Facebook Groups, Discord, and Slack, reflecting a desire for personalized interactions and deeper connections where users feel valued and heard.

Where Communities Are Thriving:

  • Facebook Groups – Still powerful for building topic-specific communities

  • Discord Servers – Perfect for real-time conversations and exclusive access

  • Slack Communities – Ideal for B2B brands and professional networking

  • Instagram Broadcast Channels – Great for one-to-many communication with your most engaged followers

  • Private Membership Sites – For premium community experiences

Social fatigue and oversaturation have driven users away from the chaos of public feeds, and they're seeking refuge in spaces that feel more intimate and purposeful.

The Business Case for Community

Building community isn't just feel-good marketing—it directly impacts your bottom line.

Community-Driven Benefits:

  1. Higher Customer Retention – Community members stick around longer

  2. Increased Lifetime Value – Engaged users buy more frequently

  3. Organic Advocacy – Your community becomes your marketing team

  4. Valuable Feedback Loop – Direct access to customer insights

  5. Lower Acquisition Costs – Word-of-mouth referrals from community members

Building and maintaining a community is the cornerstone of social media marketing success.

How to Start Building Your Community Today

1. Choose Your Platform Strategically

Don't try to be everywhere. Pick platforms where your audience naturally congregates and where you can maintain consistent engagement.

2. Create Value First, Sell Second

Brands should participate in conversations and provide value without selling. Your community should feel like a resource, not a sales pitch.

3. Establish Clear Guidelines

Set expectations for behavior, communication style, and what members can expect from your community. This creates psychological safety.

4. Facilitate Member-to-Member Connections

The strongest communities aren't brand-centric—they're member-centric. Encourage members to help each other, share experiences, and form relationships.

5. Show Up Consistently

Community building requires ongoing presence. Dedicate time daily to respond to comments, start conversations, and acknowledge contributions.

The Authenticity Advantage

When consumers rank the most important traits of brand content, they rank authenticity, relatability and entertainment first, while polished, product-centric content is ranked as least important.

Your community wants to see:

  • Real people from your team

  • Behind-the-scenes content

  • Honest conversations

  • Acknowledgment of challenges

  • Unpolished, genuine moments

Measuring Community Success

Forget follower growth as your primary KPI. Instead, track:

  • Engagement Rate – Comments, shares, saves per post

  • Active Participation – How many members regularly contribute

  • Member-Generated Content – Content created by your community

  • Response Time – How quickly conversations happen

  • Sentiment Analysis – The tone of conversations

  • Retention Rate – How many members stay active over time

The Outbound Engagement Strategy

Brands are strategically commenting on creator content, which helps them cultivate community while also putting their brand in front of new audiences.

Don't just wait for people to come to you. Go where your potential community members already are:

  • Comment thoughtfully on relevant posts

  • Join existing communities in your niche

  • Collaborate with creators who share your values

  • Participate in trending conversations authentically

Real-World Success Stories

Sephora has demonstrated the power of its exclusive Beauty Insider community where members share tips, ask questions and support each other, with the company reporting that 80% of Sephora's sales came from its loyalty members.

That's the power of community converted into revenue.

Action Items for This Week

Ready to start building? Here's your homework:

  1. Audit Your Current Community Presence – Where do your most engaged followers already gather?

  2. Start One Meaningful Conversation – Post a question that invites genuine discussion

  3. Respond to Every Comment – Show your community their voice matters

  4. Identify Your Super Fans – Who are your most engaged followers? Acknowledge them.

  5. Create a Private Space – Test a small private group or channel for your most dedicated fans

The Bottom Line

Success on social media isn't about chasing numbers—it's about building a home for your audience.

When you shift from broadcasting to community building, everything changes. Your content gets more engagement. Your brand builds deeper trust. Your marketing becomes more effective because it's powered by genuine relationships.

Community isn't just the new currency of social media—it's the only currency that really matters.

That's a wrap!

Start your newsletter & monetize it

If you are serious about starting a newsletter & monetize it to be the master of your time, I highly recommend Beehiiv.