In partnership with

The DM Dilemma: Why Most People Get It Wrong

Picture this: You've built an amazing following, your content is getting great engagement, but your bank account isn't reflecting your social media success. Sound familiar?

The missing link between followers and revenue is often a strategic DM approach. Most creators either avoid DMs entirely (leaving money on the table) or come across as pushy salespeople (damaging their reputation). Today, we're diving deep into the sweet spot that converts followers into paying clients.

The Foundation: Building DM-Worthy Relationships

Before you ever send that first direct message, you need to lay the groundwork through your public content and interactions.

The 3-Touch Rule: Engage meaningfully with someone's content at least 3 times before sliding into their DMs. This could be thoughtful comments, shares, or reactions that show you're genuinely interested in their journey.

Value-First Visibility: Make sure your recent posts demonstrate clear expertise and value in your niche. When someone checks your profile after receiving your DM, they should immediately understand what you do and how you help people.

Kickstart your holiday campaigns

CTV should be central to any growth marketer’s Q4 strategy. And with Roku Ads Manager, launching high-performing holiday campaigns is simple and effective.

With our intuitive interface, you can set up A/B tests to dial in the most effective messages and offers, then drive direct on-screen purchases via the remote with shoppable Action Ads that integrate with your Shopify store for a seamless checkout experience.

Don’t wait to get started. Streaming on Roku picks up sharply in early October. By launching your campaign now, you can capture early shopping demand and be top of mind as the seasonal spirit kicks in.

Get a $500 ad credit when you spend your first $500 today with code: ROKUADS500. Terms apply.

Holiday performance starts now.

The Strategic DM Framework: V.A.L.U.E.

V - Validate First

Start by acknowledging something specific about their content or journey. This shows you're not mass-messaging.

Example: "Hey Sarah, I loved your post about struggling with email automation. Your honesty about the learning curve really resonated with me."

A - Add Immediate Value

Share a quick tip, resource, or insight related to their challenge without asking for anything in return.

Example: "I actually faced the same issue last year and found that starting with just one simple welcome sequence made all the difference. Here's a quick template that helped me..."

L - Listen and Learn

Ask a thoughtful question that shows genuine interest in understanding their situation better.

Example: "What's been the biggest obstacle in getting your email marketing off the ground? I'm curious about your specific situation."

U - Understand Their Goals

Connect their immediate challenge to their bigger picture goals.

Example: "It sounds like you're trying to build a more predictable revenue stream for your business. Is that accurate?"

E - Extend a Soft Offer

Only after establishing rapport and understanding their needs, make a gentle suggestion about how you might help.

Example: "I've helped several entrepreneurs in similar situations streamline their email marketing. Would you be interested in a 15-minute strategy chat to see if I could offer any specific guidance for your situation?"

Platform-Specific DM Strategies

Instagram DMs

• Best times: Tuesday-Thursday, 10 AM - 2 PM

• Tone: Casual and visual-friendly

• Features to use: Voice messages for personal touch, story replies for natural conversation starters

• Character limit awareness: Keep initial messages under 1000 characters

LinkedIn DMs

• Best times: Monday-Wednesday, 8 AM - 10 AM

• Tone: Professional but personable

• Features to use: Connect requests with personalized notes, InMail for premium outreach

• Focus: Career growth, business development, professional challenges

Twitter/X DMs

• Best times: Wednesday-Friday, 9 AM - 3 PM

• Tone: Conversational and timely

• Features to use: Reply to tweets publicly first, then move to DMs for deeper conversation

• Focus: Industry insights, trending topics, quick value exchanges

The Conversation Starters That Actually Work

For Service Providers: "I noticed you mentioned [specific challenge] in your recent post. I've helped [similar people] overcome this exact issue. Mind if I share what worked for them?"

For Course Creators: "Your content about [topic] has been incredibly valuable. I'm working on something that might complement what you're already doing. Would love to get your perspective on it."

For Coaches: "I've been following your journey with [specific situation]. Your progress is inspiring! I'm curious - what's been the most surprising part of the process for you?"

Red Flags: What NOT to Do

The Pitch Slap: Never lead with your offer. It's like proposing on the first date.

The Copy-Paste Obvious: Generic messages are instantly recognizable. Always personalize.

The Desperation Follow-Up: If someone doesn't respond, don't send 5 more messages. Move on gracefully.

The Bait and Switch: Don't promise one thing and deliver another. Trust is everything in DMs.

Converting Conversations into Clients

The Discovery Process

Once someone shows interest, your goal shifts from selling to discovering:

• What's their biggest challenge right now?

• What have they already tried?

• What would success look like for them?

• What's their timeline for solving this problem?

The Natural Transition

"Based on what you've shared, it sounds like [their problem] is really holding back [their goal]. I've developed a [solution] specifically for [people like them]. Would you be open to a brief call to see if it might be a good fit?"

The Follow-Up Formula

• Immediate follow-up: Within 24 hours of your initial conversation

• Value-add follow-up: 3 days later with a relevant resource

• Check-in follow-up: 1 week later with genuine interest in their progress

• Long-term nurture: Monthly valuable insights with no sales pitch

Scaling Your DM Strategy

The 80/20 Rule for DMs

• 80% of your DM energy should go to warm prospects (people who've engaged with your content)

• 20% can be used for cold outreach to ideal prospects

Automation That Doesn't Feel Robotic

Use tools like ManyChat or Chatfuel for initial responses, but always transition to personal conversation quickly. The goal is to feel human, not efficient.

Building a DM System

1. Research Phase: 15 minutes daily identifying potential prospects

2. Engagement Phase: Interact with their content authentically

3. Outreach Phase: Send personalized DMs using the V.A.L.U.E. framework

4. Nurture Phase: Follow up consistently without being pushy

5. Convert Phase: Make soft offers when timing feels right

Measuring DM Success

Key Metrics to Track

• Response Rate: Aim for 30-40% for warm prospects, 10-15% for cold outreach

• Conversation Rate: How many responses turn into meaningful conversations

• Meeting Rate: How many conversations lead to calls or meetings

• Conversion Rate: How many meetings become paying clients

Monthly DM Audit Questions

• Which types of opening messages got the best response rates?

• What time of day/week saw the highest engagement?

• Which conversations felt most natural and led to the best outcomes?

• What objections came up most frequently, and how can I address them proactively?

Your Next Steps

1. This Week: Identify 10 followers who've recently engaged with your content and research their recent posts

2. Next Week: Send 3 strategic DMs using the V.A.L.U.E. framework

3. This Month: Track your metrics and refine your approach based on what's working

Remember: DMs aren't about quick wins. They're about building relationships that transform followers into a community of people who know, like, and trust you enough to invest in what you offer.